IP, Reports & Roadmaps | Jan 07, 2008

Patent Dispute - Next Round: Seoul Semiconductor filed a defamation lawsuit against Nichia

Seoul Semiconductor announced today that it has filed a defamation lawsuit against Nichia Corporation for Nichia’s false statements about N.D. Cal Case (“Design Case”) with Central District Court in Seoul, Korea. Seoul Semiconductor’s suit against Nichia, filed on January 7, 2008, seeks compensation for damages for defamation in the amount of 0.5 billion Korean won (approximately US$531,000).

The product, which Nichia has insisted in the US design patent lawsuit that is infringing on its patents is limited to the model number 902. The model number 902 is one of side view LEDs at 0.7 mm of thickness for backlights for LCDs of mobile phones, etc. The discontinuation of the product has already been announced to the public.

Seoul Semiconductor has endured, thus far, Nichia’s false and misrepresenting statement and libel, which are not the very heart of the patent issue. Seoul Semiconductor has finally concluded that the only way to deter on-going false statements from Nichia and to uphold the truth is to file a lawsuit, which would show Seoul Semiconductor’s firm resolution.

Last year Seoul Semiconductor sent a courtesy letter to give Nichia an opportunity to correct the false statements. However, instead of correcting its wrongful activities, Nichia replied by filing a defamation lawsuit against Seoul Semiconductor on December 28, 2007.

Nichia, at the beginning, claimed the payment of damages for the amount of millions of dollars in the US design patent lawsuit. Here are examples of false statements that Nichia has made to the public:

1. “$250 damage award rather than $62” (Untrue);
2. “The injunction will ban the sale of 902 LEDs and any other Seoul products that infringes Nichia’s patents”(Untrue).

Seoul Semiconductor cannot get along with Nichia’s false and wrongful activities anymore. Seoul Semiconductor is taking any and all necessary steps to prevent Nichia from further distortion of the truth to the public.

As a world leading company, Seoul Semiconductor strongly believes that a company’s success relies on its morality and integrity. Regardless of Nichia’s behavior, Seoul Semiconductor will continue to fulfill its duty as a public company, to conduct business in a forthright and honest manner, to protect the interest of its investors and to provide a better value to the world.

Add comment

You can add a comment by filling out the form below. Plain text formatting. Comments are moderated.

Question: What is 1 + 5 ?
Your answer:

Samsung LED Pushes Efficiency of Mid-power Packages to Higher Levels

Samsung LED Pushes Efficiency of Mid-power Packages to Higher Levels Samsung Electronics has announced that it has made an important upgrade in the luminous efficacy of its mid-power LED package. The LM301B was introduced to the market with the industry’s highest light efficacy among mid-power LED packages in 2017. Now, it has enhanced the efficacy considerably ... Read more »


LED Patent Lawsuit

Tridonic initiated patent lawsuits against telecommunication retailer S-KON eKontor24 GmbH. Although District Court Munich I affirmed Tridonic’s arguments, parties agreed on a settlement for reasons of legal certainty and prompt settlement of the dispute. Read more »


Proof Your Blue Light Hazard Risk: Stray Light Corrected CAS 140D

Proof Your Blue Light Hazard Risk: Stray Light Corrected CAS 140D With the stray light corrected CAS 140D Instrument Systems – as a technical pioneer – is the first to offer an array spectrometer that can reliably assess the blue light hazard from light sources within the prescribed limiting values. Hitherto only double monochromators were recommended for this ... Read more »


Edison Opto Unveils Two Novel-Designed Products in EdiPower Series

Edison Opto Unveils Two Novel-Designed Products in EdiPower Series Edison Opto, a global LED lighting manufacturer, unveils two new products in EdiPower Series for broad lighting applications. First, the Tunable Series with superior CRI of 95 supports two output channels to enable two dimming options to dim LED lighting without a brightness drop. In addition, the ... Read more »


High Conductive Foils Enabling Large Area Lighting

High Conductive Foils Enabling Large Area Lighting Fraunhofer Institute for Organic Electronics, Electron Beam and Plasma Technology FEP as one of the leading partners for research and development for surface technologies and organic electronics and Sefar AG, a leading manufacturer of precision fabrics from monofilaments, developed a roll-to-roll ... Read more »