IP, Reports & Roadmaps | Nov 14, 2008

DOE Report Releases Two New CALiPER Benchmark Reports

DoE recently released two new CALiPER Benchmark Reports; one comparing omni-directional incandescent lamps (A-type and small decorative, candelabra-type lamps) and their commercially available LED replacements, the other shows an analysis of halogen MR16 lamps and their commercially available LED replacements.

The results of both reports show a frustrating picture for LED replacements. Most manufacturers claim much too high values for their products. Very often the LED lamps to replace incandescent lamps produce only 10-60% of their claimed light output, while carrying claims such as “equivalent to a 25-W lamp” or “replaces a 40-W lamp” or “90% more efficient than a 60-W lamp.” MR16 LED replacement lamps were compared to 20W halogen lamps. Wide variations were observed in tested performance. Even the best performing LED replacement lamp doesn't reach the light output of the least efficient halogen lamp. DoE stated: For cases in which lower light levels are desirable, LED MR16 lamps may provide a more efficacious alternative to halogen lamps.

To help users better compare LED products with conventional lighting technologies, DOE conducts CALiPER testing of traditional (non-LED) lamps and fixtures. Benchmark Reports provide detailed analysis of test results for both traditional and LED products for a given application, comparing a range of standard lighting measures (e.g., power usage, light output and distribution, efficacy, correlated color temperature, color rendering index). Potential performance and application issues indicated by CALiPER testing results also are examined.

Additional LED reports are available for download at www.netl.doe.gov/ssl.

Add comment

You can add a comment by filling out the form below. Plain text formatting. Comments are moderated.

Question: What is 1 + 5 ?
Your answer:
EDITORIAL

Selecting the UV LED Wavelength for Purification Applications

Selecting the UV LED Wavelength for Purification Applications Patrick Durand is the Worldwide Technical Director at Future Lighting Solutions (FLS) with over 15 years of experience in the solid state lighting industry. Patrick leads the FLS Technical Marketing teams and FLS laboratory teams located in multiple regions around the world with the objective of ... Read more »

EDITORIAL

Nichia Showcases LEDs with 'Light so Good'

Nichia Showcases LEDs with 'Light so Good' At Light + Building 2020 held in Frankfurt, Nichia – the leader in high-performance LED solutions – reveals it will present at least three complementary technologies to improve the delivery of light quality under an over-arching banner of 'Light so Good'. Read more »